It’s been a while since I’ve been on this
blog. But so much hate and terror is
currently terrorizing the world that I think it’s important to be part of a
thoughtful, healing conversation.
In April 2012, commemorating Holocaust
Remembrance Day, Yom Hashoah, Avi
Benlolo—President/CEO, Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center Canada—posted a blog
entitled, “Could the Internet Have Stopped the Holocaust?” I googled the question today in the
context of my own cynicism about worldwide deadly violence and oppression currently
overwhelming online, print, and television/radio news and social media, and I
ran across Benlolo’s reflection on the power of 21st-century “digitalities”
in the hands of humans.
It’s a question I’ve asked my writing/rhetoric
students often: would the holocaust have
been able to occur in our current 24-hour/day cable/online news cycles and in
the context of instant cellphone images and social media? It’s a question I
have myself as a digital communicator
To my mind, the obvious answer is—or
should be—of course not! If the world
had just known what was really happening in Germany and Eastern Europe, they
absolutely would’ve condemned it and worked to remove Hitler and the Nazis from
power. After all, Benlolo points out
about our current digital age, “At no other time in history have ordinary
people with minimal resources at their fingertips had the opportunity to shape
the course of world events in such a dramatic way”—to create a critical mass of
equally ordinary people, from literally around the planet, virtually
instantaneously.
BUT…Benlolo qualifies his celebration of
people’s power and reach: “Had the
digital age existed and had enough
individuals been encouraged by mass social activism, one hopes the outcome would have been different.” And that’s the big IF of our age isn’t it? IF enough
individuals become aware and involved, then make sure others became aware and
involved…one hopes those individuals
would have a transformative, healing impact.
A better outcome remains only a possibility.
And here we are, July 2014.
- Pro-Russian Ukrainian rebels shoot down a commercial airliner flying from Europe to the Pacific, filled with 298 souls looking for a beach-side vacation, to reunite with loved ones, to enjoy much needed rest and relaxation with the kids before a new school year begins;
- Israel invades Gaza under the guise of stopping terrorist activity by Hamas, with over 1,400 Palestinians killed—80% civilians including children—in what seems to be an ongoing Palestinian genocide on the part of a militant Israel, home to survivors, children, and grandchildren of Hitler’s Jewish genocide;
- 200 young school girls are abducted by Islamic extremists in Nigeria because the young girls had the audacity to seek education—while some have escaped, 3 months later, no one knows where the girls are;
- Islamic extremists burst through the Syrian border into Iraq seeking outright domination, now insisting that all Iraqi females undergo genital mutilation;
- young children flee deadly violence in their Central American home countries, making a perilous trek across Mexico alone to the U.S. southern border in the summer heat, to be greeted by hate-filled, threatening Americans demanding they be return to where they came from.
And we have all the news, social media,
and up-to-the-minute cellphone images showing all the ugliness taking place in
living color. While millions have
undertaken what Benlolo envisions, the deadliness, brutality, and domination
continue.
One of Benlolo’s blog respondents argued
that surely social media, iPhone images taken from within prisoner train cars,
24-hour cable news, etc. would’ve at the least kept Hitler’s police squads busy
and distracted. But the same respondent
celebrates the idea that thanks to our global digital network and media,
nothing like the Holocaust will ever be able to happen again. That respondent must have missed Benlolo’s reference
to the Rwandan genocide that killed millions (1990s), the Bosnian genocide that
required international military intervention (1990s), and the death and
displacement of millions of Western Sudanese in a bloody civil war (2000s).
Benlolo applauds those using digital
technologies to increase awareness, to influence world political and economic
leaders, to build advocacy coalitions.
But he adds another call to action: he calls on us to care more and
sooner. Another respondent to Benlolo’s HuffPost blog agrees that certainly our
digital connectedness could’ve significantly mitigated the deadliness of the
Nazi Final Solution. But she cautions
that ongoing history makes it evident that the human race still has some
serious evolving to do before we reach a point of truly caring more and caring
sooner, before we “reach that critical mass needed to make a difference”
(annwil).
We’re great at immediate, real-time,
show-n-tell, like first-graders, eagerly posting for all our “friends” the
stories, photos, commentary, “facts,” and interpretation of those facts coming
our way in sound bites, heavily-edited news reports, and 140 characters. And many of us care. Yet many feel utterly powerless to make any
real difference, or we are absolutely overwhelmed by so much hate, violence,
destruction, & oppressive power over the many by the few that we shut down,
shut off, tune out. The ubiquity of
digital information about our world works against our caring enough to act, against
caring soon enough to prevent brutality and slaughter taking place just down
the road or across the planet.
Elie Wiesel believes love’s opposite isn’t
hate but indifference…not caring enough, not caring until it’s more convenient
or absolutely necessary, not caring at all because it’s none of our business or
it doesn’t affect us. Our digital
technologies are evolving much more rapidly than we humans; and surely we’ll
continue to increase our effectiveness at using them transformatively, sooner
and w/ greater care for our fellow inhabitants of planet Earth. But in the context of today’s world, I have
to answer Benlolo’s question with an unsatisfactory “no.” No, the Internet, wifi, the latest iPhone,
the Twitterverse, would not have
stopped the Holocaust…then or now. What
say you? What can we do now to move our
digital and human evolution forward?